The Cookie Caper is the elite custom cookie company on Cape Cod. We make high quality, small batch cookies for all occasions whether you are a business looking for logo cookies or a family hosting a meaningful event. And most importantly, the cookies taste as good as they look!

These cookies support local non-profits, so your snack break doubles as a good deed.

Bake. Give. Repeat.

Best Sellers

The cookies listed below are all made to order. Please allow 6-10 business day lead time for turnaround from order date to pickup or shipping.

Thanksgiving Preorders

Orders will be available for pickup November 24th or 25th.  Shipped orders will be sent 11/19  Deadline to order is 11/13. 

ORDER NOW!

Christmas Countdown Preorders

Orders will be available for pickup Dec 10-11.  Shipped orders will be sent 12/9.  Deadline to order is 12/1. 

ORDER NOW!

Everyday Cookie Bundles

Your favorite drop cookies, packaged in 6 packs!

SHOP NOW

Everyday Sugar Cookie Sets

Need cookies without the long wait? Our Everyday sets are preset with a 1 dozen minimum and a 7-business day turnaround. New designs added regularly!

Shop Now

Gourmet Cookies & Platters

SHOP NOW

Cookie Cakes

Shop Now

Merch

Shop now