About Us

The Cookie Caper is the elite custom cookie company on Cape Cod. We make high quality, small batch cookies for all occasions whether you are a business looking for logo cookies or a family hosting a meaningful event. And most importantly, the cookies taste as good as they look!

These cookies support local non-profits, so your snack break doubles as a good deed.

Bake. Give. Repeat.

SHOP NOW

Best Sellers

The cookies listed below are all made to order. Please allow 6-10 business day lead time for turnaround from order date to pickup or shipping.

Teacher Appreciation Week

Deadline to order is 5/1.  Pickup 5/4 or 5/5 in Yarmouth Port.  Shipped orders will be sent by 5/4 if ordered by 4/28.  

Order Here

Nurse Appreciation Week

Deadline to order is 5/1.  Pickup 5/4 or 5/5 in Yarmouth Port.  Shipped orders will be sent by 5/4 if ordered by 4/28.  

Order Here

Graduation Orders

Made to order Graduation orders. 7 business day turnaround time.

Order Here

Mother's Day

Deadline to order is 5/1.  Pickup 5/8 or 5/9 in Yarmouth Port.  Shipped orders will be sent by 5/5 if ordered by 4/28.  

Order Here

Everyday Cookie Bundles

Your favorite drop cookies, packaged in 6 packs!

SHOP NOW

Everyday Sugar Cookie Sets

Need cookies without the long wait? Our Everyday sets are preset with a 1 dozen minimum and a 7-business day turnaround. New designs added regularly!

Shop Now

Gourmet Cookies & Platters

SHOP NOW

Cookie Cakes

Shop Now

Merch

Shop now